Reviewed by:
What the book club told us about the book:
Our School Review
What our pupils thought
” I enjoyed the relationship between Ed and Elodie, Elodie being better than Ed at everything, then when his powers were revealed to be powerful she told him not to boast about them.”
” My favourite parts were the dream that Ed sent to Elodie where she was flying, and the nightmare that both of the twins were sucked into, that then kept Elodie in the world of nightmares.”
” I enjoyed the Sculptor’s Cave and the feel of calm and peacefulness Ed found there.”
” I liked the anticipation and the excitement of the power revealing ceremony. That the twins had the same power of the hidden and unseen. I really liked the descriptions of the colours of their individual auras. I also liked that originally Ed thought his powers were boring and not very impressive. The way he managed to get the dream world and nightmare world to work together was really good.”
Out of 5 stars, the pupils give this book:
About the book club:



What our educators thought
“We ran our book club for year 5 & 6 for this book and the children really enjoyed it. The diversity in this book is done in a way that it is just part of the story and not a focal point or exaggerated with unnecessary drama. The love between the family of two dads and the adopted twins creates a wonderfully strong bond. Nyx, with a pronoun they, is a great character that the children just seem to focus on their magical talent. The relationship between the twins, Ed and Elodie, covers a range of sibling emotions, love, friendship, anger and jealousy. This creates some great talking points with children about their own families and relationships. Similarly, the dynamic between Ed and his bully, Greg, changes the focus on who you feel sorry for throughout the book. Creating a discussion on retaliating against a bully and if it is every acceptable. The fantasy world of dreams compared to the world of nightmares raising the subject of what is scary to one person might not be to another, and what one person dreams of can be the opposite for other people. There could be some interesting illustrations linked to reading this book based on different perspectives. I can’t wait to read book 2.”
Out of 5 stars, the educator gives this book:
Get involved
Looking to get involved in the Reviewer’s Book Club. We’re always on the look out for the latest page-turners and top-notch school book clubs ready to go on a literary adventure with us.
Publishers
If you’re a publisher with fresh reads for primary schools that you’d love us to review, then get in touch by emailing: submissions@wherereadingrocks.com
School book clubs
The wait list for reviewers is currently closed due to popular demand, watch this space or sign up to our newsletter to know when the list re-opens.








